The short answer
Between 2021 and 2023, 354 dietary supplements were recalled in France over ethylene oxide, a sterilizing gas classified as carcinogenic. If you took one of them, the risk is low and concerns the long term: no poisoning has been reported, and there are no symptoms to watch for.
What remains concerning is the lesson from this case. A gas banned in the European Union ended up in turmeric, vitamin B12 and red vine leaf capsules, sold in pharmacies and organic shops alike, because an imported ingredient had been treated on the other side of the world.
This crisis alone accounts for nearly half of the 724 recalls recorded by the dietary supplement recall observatory. Here is where it came from, what the risk really means, and where things stand in 2026.
A sterilizing gas in your capsules
Ethylene oxide is primarily a chemical industry product. According to the International Agency for Research on Cancer, only a tiny share of production, around 0.05%, is used directly as a gas: to sterilize medical equipment that cannot withstand heat, and as a fumigant or insecticide.
In the United States, it sterilizes around half of all sterilized medical devices. The US Environmental Protection Agency also cites an estimate from the American Spice Trade Association: around 40% of dried spices there are reportedly treated with ethylene oxide each year to kill bacteria and insects. In Singapore, the permitted limit in spices is as high as 50 mg/kg.
The European Union took the opposite path:
- as a pesticide, ethylene oxide has been banned since a 1986 directive, with exemptions for spices and dried plants that expired by the end of 1989 at the latest
- for treating food, it has been banned since 2011, according to the DGCCRF and Germany’s Federal Institute for Risk Assessment, the BfR
- on your plate, the residue limit is set at the lowest level laboratories can measure: 0.02 to 0.1 mg/kg depending on the food, counting ethylene oxide together with 2-chloroethanol, the molecule it forms on contact with food
For supplements, the European Commission clarified in 2021 that the applicable limit is 0.1 mg/kg, including for the capsule shells used to make them. A spice that is legal in Singapore can therefore contain 500 times the European limit.
From sesame seed to capsule: the timeline
It all began on September 9, 2020. Belgium reported ethylene oxide in sesame seeds from India through the European alert system, RASFF. The levels detected were more than a thousand times higher than the 0.05 mg/kg limit. At a crisis meeting on October 9, 2020, member states learned that the affected batches had been distributed in 24 EU countries and 9 non-EU countries. All sesame above the limit, and any product containing it, had to be withdrawn.
In 2021, the issue grew in scale. Indian guar gum was flagged in April, followed by locust bean gum, the additive E410, in June. These thickeners are found in ice cream, sauces and supplements. In July 2021, European crisis coordinators concluded that no safe level of exposure could be defined, and that any exposure therefore poses a potential risk. Belgium and Denmark then criticized this zero-tolerance approach.
France applied it strictly. The government called for the withdrawal and recall of products containing a contaminated ingredient “at any dose whatsoever”. The scale was huge: according to the DGCCRF’s 2021 activity report, 4,681 consumer product references were recalled from January to November 2021, covering 13,825 batches. Half of the 3,070 alerts handled by the DGCCRF that year concerned ethylene oxide.
The EU then responded on three fronts:
- at the border, a December 2021 regulation required an official certificate and checks on 20% of batches of several Indian products, including guar gum, spices and herbal supplements
- in additives, an August 2022 regulation banned any residue above 0.1 mg/kg, regardless of its origin
- in recalls, guidelines adopted in September 2023 made withdrawal above a calculated limit for the finished product the default rule, reserving withdrawal solely on traceability grounds for highly exceptional circumstances
354 supplement recalls: what the data show
The observatory links 354 RappelConso supplement notices to ethylene oxide, covering 169 different brands. That is 49% of all supplement recalls published since RappelConso launched in April 2021. Recalls from the early months of the crisis, in late 2020, are therefore not included.
The timeline shows a wave, followed by an aftershock:
- 2021: 291 recalls, or 92% of that year’s supplement recalls, peaking at 82 notices in September
- 2022: 46 recalls
- 2023: 17 recalls, including a series from October to December involving organic red vine leaf capsules and “circulation” or “slimming” blends
- since 2024: no supplement recalls for this reason
Only 52 of these recalls were ordered by the authorities. The others are described as voluntary, which says nothing about their severity: the brand initiates the recall itself, without a prefectural order. 136 notices specify that the contamination came from a raw material or ingredient.
The ingredients involved
Turmeric appears in 63 recalled products, pepper in 14 and ginger in 11, either in their names or in the reason for recall. These are spices, precisely the products treated with gas in some exporting countries. If you take turmeric, the article on curcumin and its absorption also explains why pepper is so often added to the same capsule.
Two other sources show how the chain works:
- one raw material, several brands: 16 notices from four brands, including 15 published between November 10 and 15, 2021, cite a contaminated vitamin B12 raw material containing 1% methylcobalamin, often in identical terms. RASFF reported contaminated vitamin B12 from Spain that same year
- the capsule itself: 19 notices implicate the capsule shell, made from hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC), a plant-derived cellulose. RASFF reported contaminated shells from China. The “plant-based” capsule, chosen for its more natural image, was sometimes the contaminated part
A supplement is an assembly of ingredients: plant powders, vitamin premixes, additives and a shell. Each ingredient has its own supplier, often abroad, and a single contaminated batch can end up in products from dozens of brands. This explains the number of brands affected more than negligence by each one.
What is the risk to your health?
The hazard is real
IARC classifies ethylene oxide as carcinogenic to humans, in Group 1, the category with the strongest evidence. This classification rests on three elements: limited evidence in humans for lymphoid cancers and breast cancer, sufficient evidence in animals, and a well-established genotoxic mechanism. The molecule directly damages DNA. The European Union also classifies it as mutagenic and toxic to reproduction.
One point changes how this should be read: the human data come from 14 cohorts of workers exposed through inhalation in chemical plants or sterilization facilities. These were not spice consumers.
The risk, however, is low
For a genotoxic carcinogen, the BfR considers that there is no no-effect threshold. It calculated an intake level of low concern: 0.037 µg per kilogram of body weight per day, corresponding to one additional cancer case per 100,000 people exposed throughout their lives. The BfR stresses that this benchmark is not a measure of a food’s safety.
Applied to sesame at the 0.05 mg/kg limit, its 2021 calculation shows that this benchmark is not exceeded in either children or adults with average long-term consumption. Only a child eating a large 23.4 g portion every day would exceed it.
To give a sense of scale, a 500 mg capsule containing exactly 0.1 mg/kg delivers 0.05 µg of ethylene oxide. For a 70 kg adult, that is around 0.0007 µg per kilogram, fifty times lower than the BfR benchmark. This calculation has a clear limitation: recall notices do not publish the measured concentrations, and some batches exceeded the limit by a wide margin.
The authorities that have communicated about the risk take a similar view. The DGCCRF described a possible long-term risk from consumption, noting that it had received no reports of poisoning. Luxembourg’s food safety authority referred to a potential chronic risk, meaning daily consumption in large quantities over a lifetime.
The case of 2-chloroethanol
Some contamination mainly involved 2-chloroethanol, which 15 supplement notices explicitly mention. Its hazardous properties remain under debate. In 2022, the European Food Safety Authority considered the data on its genotoxicity inconclusive. In February 2026, the BfR concluded that a mutagenic effect at dietary doses was unlikely and proposed a provisional acceptable daily intake. This opinion relies partly on industry-provided data, and a joint European assessment is still pending.
Two philosophies, one molecule
The US agency concludes that dietary risks from ethylene oxide are not of concern. The EU considers that no dose can be described as safe. The two positions do not assess the same thing: the first estimates risk at actual exposure levels, while the second rejects the presence in food of a genotoxic carcinogen already banned within its territory.
For you, the practical conclusion is the same. Having taken a recalled supplement for a few weeks does not warrant particular concern. The real problem was the presence of a substance that had no business being there.
Organic and made in France: what does not protect you
88 of the 354 recalls, or a quarter, involved products presented as organic. Ethylene oxide is banned in organic farming just as elsewhere, but imported organic ingredients were contaminated. In 2021, the European Commission required testing of every batch of organic Indian sesame, and five Indian certification bodies were removed from the European list for unprocessed plant products from 2022 onward.
The 2023 aftershock was partly linked to a European ingredient. RASFF reported contaminated organic red vine leaves originating in France and Spain, and a May 2023 notice explicitly cites a European alert concerning a batch of organic red vine leaves.
The lesson is simple: the organic label certifies a production method, and “made in France” identifies the place of assembly. Neither guarantees that every ingredient has been tested for this contaminant.
Is it over?
In France, no supplement has been recalled over ethylene oxide since December 2023. In RASFF, I counted notifications mentioning the molecule: 449 in 2021, 176 in 2022, 55 in 2023, 35 in 2024, 27 in 2025 and 16 in 2026, up to November 18. Among the most recent were Indian boswellia and, on October 30, 2026, Indian plant extracts.
Elsewhere, the issue resurfaced. In April 2024, the Hong Kong Centre for Food Safety found ethylene oxide in four spice blends from two major Indian brands and advised against consuming them.
European checks remain in place. The regulation in force since June 2026 still requires a certificate for several Indian products, with checks on 20% of turmeric, ginger and other spice batches, and on 10% of herbal supplement batches.
This decline needs some qualification. Since 2023, a multi-ingredient product is generally recalled only if it exceeds its calculated limit. It is difficult to say how much of the decline comes from cleaner raw materials and how much from less stringent withdrawal rules.
What to do in practice
It comes down to a few points:
- Check your brand in the observatory or on RappelConso if you still have old bottles bought between 2020 and 2023. Most are past their expiry date by now anyway.
- Do not look for symptoms. The estimated risk concerns prolonged exposure, not a few weeks of capsules. If you are worried, talk to your doctor or pharmacist, bringing the product name and recall notice.
- Ask for batch test results for plant powders and spices in capsules. A reputable brand can provide a certificate of analysis covering pesticides and ethylene oxide. The article on counterfeit supplements · FR explains how to read this document.
- Be wary of direct imports. A turmeric supplement bought from a US or Asian website may contain spices legally treated in their country of origin, at concentrations banned in Europe.
- Cut down on bottles. Each product in the Pill Cupboard, that stockpile of supplements you take without knowing which does what, adds its own supply chain. Fewer products mean fewer ingredients whose origins you cannot control.
Ethylene oxide is not the observatory’s only wave of recalls. The second, in 2025, involved a plant suspended over direct toxicity concerns: that is the subject of the article on garcinia cambogia banned in France.





