The short answer
No trial has shown that field horsetail strengthens hair, nails or bones. The only use recognised by the European Medicines Agency is traditional and urinary: increasing urine output in cases of minor urinary complaints. And it is one of the most frequently recalled plants in France, with 22 supplement recalls, almost all due to pesticides.
The sales pitch comes down to one word: silicon. Horsetail contains plenty of it, and silicon is a component of connective tissue. But Europe reviewed this claim and rejected it, and the plant itself has never been tested on its own for hair.
That does not make it a harmless plant. It remains well tolerated over short periods, but it has a few little-known pitfalls, from vitamin B1 to HIV treatments.
Silicon: an argument that does not hold up
Field horsetail, Equisetum arvense, is rich in silica. A Polish analysis measured around 27 mg of silicon per gram of horsetail in tea bags, or nearly 3% of the plant’s weight. But the same study observed an approximately 50-fold drop in silicon concentration during brewing. The EMA assessment report points in the same direction: only a small proportion of the plant’s silica passes into the water.
Silicon itself has never been shown to be essential in humans. In 2004, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) noted this in its opinion on upper intake levels, estimating usual dietary intake at between 20 and 50 mg per day.
In 2011, EFSA examined the claims about silicon. Its conclusion was negative for all of them: collagen formation, bones, joints, skin, hair and nails. The trials submitted in support did not actually study horsetail, but a form of silicon stabilized with choline:
- on hair and nails, a 2005 trial in 50 women compared improvement only with baseline, not with placebo
- on hair, a 2007 trial in 48 women found slightly less brittle hair, but EFSA could draw no conclusions because no primary endpoint had been defined in advance
- on bones, a 2008 trial in 184 women found no effect on bone density
In other words, even the best-studied form of silicon failed to convince. Horsetail hasn’t even been put through that test.
What trials on horsetail show
Human studies on horsetail are few and small, and none looks at hair, nails or bones using the plant alone:
- hair: the most-cited trial, in 60 women over 3 months, tested a blend of marine proteins, horsetail, acerola, biotin and zinc, funded by its manufacturer. There is no way to attribute the effect to horsetail
- joints: a study of 13 patients, with no control group, using five plants and vitamin B1
- urination: a 2014 Brazilian trial in 36 healthy men found a diuretic effect comparable to that of a diuretic drug over 4 days, but the EMA considers the trial insufficient
- blood pressure: a 2022 trial in 58 people with hypertension compared horsetail with a diuretic, with no placebo group
The US database LiverTox sums up the situation: claims about arthritis or osteoporosis have not been supported by controlled trials in humans.
One final detail concerns the label. In a analysis published in 2026, one horsetail supplement contained nearly one-eighth of the stated amount of silicon, while another slightly exceeded the European limit for cadmium.
What Europe actually recognizes
The European Medicines Agency monograph (EMA), adopted in 2016, recognizes only traditional use, based on longstanding use rather than trials:
- by mouth, to increase urine output to flush the urinary tract, as an adjunct for minor urinary complaints
- on the skin, to help treat small superficial wounds
Hair, nails and bones are not listed. In 2025, the EMA launched a call for data to revise this document.
On the nutrition side, EFSA examined claims about horsetail for skin, hair, bones and vitality back in 2009. It judged the plant too poorly characterised to assess them. These claims are among the botanical claims whose assessment was suspended in 2013. The 2012 regulation allows these pending claims to remain in use.
The irony? A hair claim can still appear on a box of horsetail because Europe never finished assessing it. The same claim was rejected for silicon—the very selling point of the plant.
In France, field horsetail is authorised in food supplements—its aerial parts only—with no specific restrictions under the order of 24 June 2014.
22 recalls, almost all due to pesticides
The dietary supplement recall tracker lists 22 recalls of horsetail supplements across 15 brands. It is one of the most frequently recalled plants on the site, behind garcinia, turmeric and aloe. The breakdown:
- 16 recalls due to pesticides, and 3 others classified as “contaminants” whose descriptions also specify pesticide levels exceeding the limits
- 2 recalls due to E. coli bacteria in March 2023, and 1 due to microbial contamination that prevented analysis
- successive waves: 6 recalls in late 2021, 6 in spring 2023, 3 in December 2023 and 7 in December 2025
Most of the recalled products were labelled organic. Where the recall notices name the chemicals, they include herbicides and fungicides. An organic horsetail product recalled in April 2023 contained 0.24 mg per kilo of MCPA, a weedkiller, against a limit of 0.1 mg. Other notices mention fomesafen, diflubenzuron, myclobutanil or trifloxystrobin.
In December 2025, seven brands published the same reason within a few days: “detection of pesticides in organic horsetail powder”, without naming the chemical. The identical wording suggests a shared raw material, but none of the notices says so. In December 2023, two products from a pharmacy brand were recalled for the same reason. The affected batches had been on sale since May 2021.
I haven’t found any source explaining why horsetail is more affected than other plants. The finding alone is enough: if you have a box, check its batch in the monitoring database.
The risks to know about
At traditional doses and over a few weeks, the EMA reports only mild digestive issues and allergic reactions. But several points deserve attention.
Vitamin B1 and raw powder
Horsetail contains thiaminase, an enzyme that destroys vitamin B1. According to the EMA report, this enzyme is destroyed by heat at 80 °C and is absent from industrial water or alcohol extracts. For unheated plant powder, found in many capsules, toxicity cannot be ruled out, although it is not expected at traditional doses. Canada requires horsetail products to be free of thiaminase activity. In horses, which may eat it in hay, horsetail has caused disorders that resolved with vitamin B1.
Confusion with marsh horsetail
Another species, marsh horsetail, Equisetum palustre, contains a potentially toxic alkaloid, palustrine. According to the EMA, the European Pharmacopoeia specifies a test to rule out its presence. A 2019 study measured levels of 20–800 mg per kilogram in this species. One more reason not to pick your own horsetail.
Sodium, potassium, liver, pancreas
Isolated cases have been published:
- sodium imbalances, including severe hyponatremia, a dangerous drop in sodium, after horsetail juice
- hepatitis in a man who already had hepatitis B, after 500 ml of juice a day for 2 weeks, around 8 times the traditional dose, with a return to normal within 8 weeks of stopping
- recurrent pancreatitis in a 56-year-old woman, which stopped when she stopped drinking horsetail tea
LiverTox classifies horsetail as a probable rare cause of liver injury. These are isolated cases and cannot be used to estimate how often this occurs.
HIV treatments
Two patients treated with an efavirenz-based antiretroviral experienced treatment failure while taking horsetail. In laboratory studies, the plant also inhibits certain enzymes that clear medications, although no cases have been documented so far, according to the EMA.
If you take it anyway
If you insist on taking horsetail for the use recognized by the EMA, a few rules can limit the risks:
- choose an extract over raw plant powder, because of thiaminase
- keep it short-term : 2 to 4 weeks based on traditional use, and seek medical advice if urinary symptoms last more than a week
- drink enough fluids, as the EMA requires for forms other than herbal tea
- check the batch in the recall tracker
- avoid it if you have severe heart or kidney disease, during pregnancy or breastfeeding, if you are under 12, or if you are taking HIV medication
For hair, the right approach starts elsewhere. Significant or sudden hair loss warrants a medical assessment, which can check for causes such as iron deficiency or a thyroid disorder. The article on hair supplements · FR compares the formulas on sale, and the one on baldness · FR details treatments that have proven effective.
When to seek medical advice
Horsetail is not the answer to a persistent symptom. The EMA itself sets the limits:
- seek medical advice if you have a fever, burning when urinating, spasms or blood in your urine
- seek medical advice if urinary problems last longer than a week
- seek medical advice in case of sudden, patchy or substantial hair loss
- seek medical advice if you have heart or kidney disease, or are on long-term medication





