Post-traumatic stress and addictions: written exposure shows promise, but comparisons remain scarce

Could a brief therapy have a place in the combined treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder and substance use disorder? A systematic review reports encouraging results for written exposure therapy. But the improvements observed before and after treatment cannot, on their own, isolate its effectiveness.

An open notebook and a pen illustrating written exposure therapy.
MindsetEditorial illustration, not study data.

Twelve studies reviewed, six pooled in the meta-analysis

The researchers examined written exposure therapy, known as WET, as a component of integrated care for these two disorders. Their review includes twelve studies, six of which were pooled in a random-effects meta-analysis.

The abstract consulted specifies neither the total sample size nor the follow-up duration. It also does not allow a precise description of the other components of the treatments received. The findings therefore concern the integration of this therapy into care, not necessarily its use alone.

A reduction in symptoms, without evidence of superiority

The analysis finds a large reduction in post-traumatic stress severity between the start and end of treatment: Hedges’ g reaches 1.18, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.68 to 1.72. This measure expresses a standardized change in symptoms, not a proportion of people who have recovered.

The crucial distinction is the comparator: a before-and-after improvement does not demonstrate that written exposure works better than another therapy. A lack of comparator groups and small samples are among the limitations noted by the authors.

Favorable acceptability, poorly documented effects on addictions

The reported retention rate is 69.03%. Most participants and clinicians consider the approach feasible and acceptable. A minority of participants, however, find simultaneous treatment of the two disorders burdensome.

Information on changes in substance use disorder remains limited. The reduction in post-traumatic symptoms therefore does not establish an equivalent improvement in substance use. These findings concern an integrated therapeutic intervention, not personal writing done alone.

Limitations to keep in mind

This synthesis is based solely on the PubMed abstract, without consulting the full text. The studies have small samples and lack comparator groups. Treatment components and changes in substance use disorders are insufficiently documented. Funding and conflicts of interest have not been checked.

What we can take away

Written exposure appears to be a promising component of combined treatment for post-traumatic stress and addictions. Its superiority over other approaches and its effects on substance use remain to be established.

Sources and provenance

Partager cet article

X f in

An error or a source to report? Contact the editorial team.