Intrusive traumatic memories: a paper-based exercise shows benefit in a small trial

Can a paper-based exercise reduce traumatic memories that intrude involuntarily? A randomized trial involving 40 patients with trauma-related disorders suggests a benefit after a single session. But the finding concerns one memory selected by each patient, with follow-up limited to the two weeks after the intervention.

Illustration of a mental rotation task featuring tubular figures on a sheet of paper.
MindsetEditorial illustration, not study data.

A mental rotation exercise compared with a control condition

The researchers evaluated “Tube figures,” a paper-based mental rotation task. It belongs to a family of interventions designed to compete with the mental imagery associated with intrusive memories. This rationale is a hypothesis about how it works, not a demonstration of the mechanism in this trial.

The study, conducted at a single center and described as randomized and single-blind, compared two groups: the Tube figures intervention and a control condition called “Wikipedia.” The available abstract does not adequately specify what this condition involved or who was blinded.

Each participant chose one intrusive memory to record daily for four weeks. After two weeks of observation, an intervention or control session was delivered. The primary outcome was the weekly frequency of that memory over the following two weeks.

A greater reduction in the tracked memory

The frequency of the tracked memory decreased by 22% in the intervention group, compared with 2% in the control group, relative to the two weeks before the session. The authors report a statistically significant difference. However, the abstract provides neither absolute frequencies nor uncertainty intervals, so these percentages do not tell us how many episodes were avoided.

The symptom score measured using the PTSD Checklist for DSM-5, or PCL-5, fell from 53 to 38 in the intervention group, compared with 55 to 47 in the control group. The authors also report a significantly greater reduction with Tube figures. These averages do not demonstrate that the disorder resolved or that every patient benefited equally.

A screen-free approach, not yet an established practice

The paper-based format offers potential value in settings without digital resources. The trial provides an initial favorable signal for this version, but does not compare it directly with a digital intervention.

The small sample, self-reported measures and short follow-up limit the scope of the findings. It remains unknown whether the improvement persists or extends to memories other than the one tracked. The authors also call for a clearer distinction between the intervention’s active components and further study of the practical conditions for its use.

Limitations to keep in mind

Only the PubMed abstract was consulted, not the full text. The study involves 40 patients at a single center, with self-reported measures and two weeks of follow-up after the intervention. The abstract does not detail adverse effects. Funding and conflicts of interest were not verified.

What we can take away

This trial suggests that one session of Tube figures could reduce a targeted intrusive traumatic memory in the short term. It is not enough to establish lasting effectiveness or to recommend an exercise to try on your own.

Sources and provenance

Partager cet article

X f in

An error or a source to report? Contact the editorial team.