A synthesis of reviews, not a new trial
The researchers brought together 13 systematic reviews covering different forms of art therapy for schizophrenia: music, dance, drama, horticulture, visual arts and multimodal approaches. Their search covered eleven databases through December 2025.
The analysis focused on positive, negative and cognitive symptoms. For effect estimates, the authors included only randomized trials or the subsets of reviews corresponding to those trials. The abstract consulted does not specify the total sample size, intervention durations or comparators used.
A favorable signal, especially for negative symptoms
Estimates for negative symptoms generally favored art therapy. The authors highlight music therapy as a possible avenue, but not as an intervention with firmly established effectiveness.
For positive symptoms, the findings do not allow a conclusion. For cognitive abilities, only one eligible review provided a synthesis, although other primary studies had measured these outcomes. This limited coverage prevents a sufficiently well-supported assessment.
The abstract does not quantify the size of the clinical benefit. It therefore cannot tell us how much improvement a person might expect or which artistic approach would be preferable.
Why accumulating reviews is not enough
Of the 13 reviews, eleven had low or very low methodological quality. Among the 28 effect estimates assessed, three had moderate certainty, sixteen low certainty and nine very low certainty. None had high certainty.
Some reviews shared the same primary studies, so their findings do not represent separate, independent confirmations. Some estimates were also sensitive to blinded assessment and publication bias.
Another limitation: the authors used the trial risk-of-bias assessments reported in the source reviews, without independently reassessing them using the original reports.
What these findings change
This synthesis supports further evaluation of art therapy as a complementary intervention, especially for negative symptoms. It is not enough to establish a firm clinical recommendation. The authors call for better-conducted reviews and adequately powered randomized trials.
Limitations to keep in mind
This draft is based solely on the supplied PubMed abstract, without consulting the full text. Intervention details, adverse effects, funding and conflicts of interest could not be verified.
What we can take away
A benefit for negative symptoms is possible, but the current evidence neither allows it to be quantified here nor supports a firm conclusion that art therapy is effective.
Sources and provenance
- Art therapy for core symptoms in schizophrenia: An umbrella review.
Source date: 2026-11-20.
Journal Article, Systematic Review · Résumé PubMed uniquement, texte intégral non consulté


