Overweight in South Asia: BMI thresholds substantially change estimates

How many people are classified as overweight or obese? In India, Bangladesh and Nepal, the answer depends heavily on the body mass index threshold used. A systematic review reports substantially higher estimates with Asian thresholds than with global thresholds. This finding concerns population monitoring, not evidence of individual risk.

Map of India, Bangladesh and Nepal alongside the BMI thresholds being compared.
NutritionEditorial illustration, not study data.

Two thresholds, different estimates

The researchers synthesised studies using nationally representative data from the three countries. Their search covered publications from 2015 to 2026, drawing on surveys conducted from 2011 onwards. Overlapping surveys were grouped together to avoid counting the same data more than once.

The abstract notably compares a global BMI threshold of 25 kg/m² with an Asian threshold of 23 kg/m². Lowering this cutoff automatically increases the proportion of people classified as overweight or obese. That does not mean their health changed when they were reclassified.

In Bangladesh, an increase over time

Among Bangladeshi women of reproductive age, the prevalence of overweight and obesity more than doubled between 2011 and 2022, reaching 55.3% using the Asian threshold. This figure applies to this population and this specific criterion: it describes neither the entire Bangladeshi population nor obesity alone.

The authors also report associations with greater household wealth, higher educational attainment and urban residence. Obstetric factors, including a higher number of deliveries and caesarean delivery, were also associated with the outcomes. These associations do not demonstrate causation.

The lack of dietary measurements limits interpretation

The abstract highlights that diet and physical activity were rarely measured directly. The data therefore mainly describe socioeconomic profiles associated with overweight, without precisely identifying the behaviours that might explain these differences.

The authors recommend thresholds adapted to Asian populations in national reports, alongside validated dietary and behavioural measures. The aim is to count more accurately and understand more clearly. However, this review does not test whether changing a threshold alone improves prevention or health.

Limitations to keep in mind

Only the PubMed abstract was consulted. The number of studies and participants, heterogeneity, study quality assessment and statistical uncertainties are not specified in the excerpt. Funding and conflicts of interest could not be verified.

What we can take away

The BMI threshold is essential for interpreting an overweight statistic. This review makes the case for monitoring tailored to South Asian populations, but provides no new guidance for individuals.

Sources and provenance

Partager cet article

X f in

An error or a source to report? Contact the editorial team.