Mental health among refugee women: screening practices remain poorly documented in the United States

Using a mental health questionnaire is not enough to know whether it is appropriate and accepted by the people concerned. Among adult refugee and asylum-seeking women in the United States, a systematic review primarily identifies a lack of data on these conditions of use. Only three included studies focused specifically on this population.

Illustration of a mental health screening interview with a refugee woman.
MindsetEditorial illustration, not study data.

A review focused on screening implementation

The authors examined the use of screening tools for depression, anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder. The abstract specifically mentions the PHQ-9, GAD-7 and PCL-5, questionnaires used to identify symptoms of these disorders.

The aim was not to test a treatment, but to examine four dimensions of implementation: tool adoption, appropriateness for the setting, acceptability and adherence to intended use. These dimensions help distinguish between having a questionnaire available in a service and how it is actually used there.

The search covered ten databases, with no restrictions on language or publication year. Of 2,011 records identified, 37 studies were included. However, only three specifically concerned adult refugee and asylum-seeking women in the United States.

Favorable findings, but within a narrow scope

These three studies reported qualitative data on the appropriateness and acceptability of screening, with findings described as positive in the abstract. This suggests that some of the approaches studied could be considered appropriate and acceptable. However, the abstract does not specify which approaches or in what settings.

This finding demonstrates neither the diagnostic accuracy of the questionnaires in this population nor an improvement in mental health following their use. A tool’s acceptability, its ability to identify a disorder and its effects on the care pathway are separate questions.

The main finding is a knowledge gap

The authors highlight limited data and inconsistent reporting of implementation outcomes. The review therefore cannot reliably establish how these tools are adopted and used with the women concerned.

This lack of data does not mean that screening is useless or inappropriate. Above all, it prevents any conclusion that the conditions needed for relevant and culturally appropriate use are sufficiently documented. The authors call for research explicitly dedicated to these processes.

Limitations to keep in mind

Only the supplied PubMed abstract was consulted, not the full text. It does not detail the sample sizes of the three relevant studies, their settings or their methodological quality. Funding and conflicts of interest cannot be verified from this excerpt. The findings concern the United States and cannot be directly extrapolated to France.

What we can take away

This review highlights a research gap, not a demonstrated failure of screening. Some qualitative findings are favorable, but they are not enough to establish the effectiveness of screening practices among refugee and asylum-seeking women.

Sources and provenance

Partager cet article

X f in

An error or a source to report? Contact the editorial team.