Comparing exertion rather than ranking pitches
The researchers compiled studies involving footballers performing football-specific activities. Each study had to include natural or artificial turf as a comparison condition. The literature search, conducted across three scientific databases, covered publications up to 17 June 2026.
Of 814 records identified, 16 studies were included. Their methods, comparisons and measurements differed too much to allow a pooled quantitative synthesis. The authors therefore conducted a narrative synthesis: it describes trends without providing a single average effect.
The differences mainly concern running
Movement is the area most sensitive to the playing surface. Several studies report more sprints, accelerations or total distance on artificial turf. Others, however, find no notable difference compared with natural turf. Running more therefore does not mean that artificial turf consistently improves performance.
Sand shows a more consistent pattern: it increases metabolic cost and reduces running efficiency. This describes an additional demand, not proof that training on sand produces better long-term results.
Heart rate and lactate findings vary. According to the authors, exercise demands, player characteristics and familiarity with the surface could also influence this internal load.
The mechanical properties of playing surfaces remain poorly documented
Neuromuscular measurements show little immediate variation. However, isolated findings indicate greater residual hamstring fatigue after exposure to artificial turf. This limited signal is not enough to establish a general effect.
The main weakness is the lack of objective pitch measurements: shock absorption, deformation and rotational traction are rarely documented. The label “natural” or “artificial” is therefore not enough to explain the observed differences. Players’ perceptions are also inconsistent and seem to depend on their familiarity with the pitch.
Limitations to keep in mind
This analysis relies solely on the PubMed abstract, without consulting the full text. The abstract does not specify total sample sizes, exposure durations or effect sizes. Study heterogeneity and the lack of mechanical measurements limit the conclusions. Funding and conflicts of interest were not checked.
What we can take away
The surface can affect the load of a football exercise, but this review identifies no universally superior pitch. Its main contribution is to show why the surface and context must be described to interpret measured exertion.
Sources and provenance
- Playing Surface Characteristics and Their Effects on Football Performance Across Multiple Surface Types: A Systematic Review.
Source date: 2026-11-13.
Journal Article, Systematic Review · Résumé PubMed uniquement, texte intégral non consulté


