Neck pain: exercises reduce fear of movement in a small trial

Being less afraid to move does not necessarily mean having less pain. In 68 people with nonspecific neck pain, a randomized trial suggests that adding stabilization exercises to physiotherapy reduces fear-avoidance beliefs after eight weeks. However, the available abstract does not establish a reduction in pain or better return-to-work outcomes.

Illustration of the neck and shoulder blades, the areas targeted by the stabilization exercises compared in the trial.
TrainingEditorial illustration, not study data.

Three treatment approaches compared over eight weeks

The trial, conducted at three hospitals, assigned participants to three groups: conventional physiotherapy alone, physiotherapy with neck stabilization exercises, or physiotherapy with neck and shoulder blade stabilization exercises. The median age was 54 years.

Treatment was delivered three times a week for eight weeks. The researchers assessed fear-avoidance beliefs at baseline, four weeks and eight weeks, using a questionnaire that distinguishes between physical activity and work. This frequency describes the intervention studied, not a prescription applicable to all neck pain.

An improvement in beliefs, not proof of pain relief

At eight weeks, both groups combining exercises with physiotherapy showed a greater reduction in fear-avoidance scores than the group receiving physiotherapy alone. This finding concerns beliefs about physical activity and work, not pain intensity directly.

Adding shoulder blade exercises showed no statistically significant advantage on the physical activity dimension compared with neck exercises alone. This lack of a significant difference does not demonstrate that the two approaches are equivalent.

For the work-related dimension, the combination of neck and shoulder blade exercises produced a better result. The reported mean difference was 8.06 points, with a 95% confidence interval ranging from 0.44 to 15.68 points. The abstract provides no threshold for determining whether this difference represents a meaningful improvement for patients.

What this trial tells us

These findings support the potential value of adding stabilization exercises to physiotherapy to reduce fear-avoidance beliefs in people with nonspecific neck pain. They are not enough to conclude that exercising the shoulder blades is consistently preferable.

The follow-up presented ends at eight weeks. The abstract reports neither longer-term maintenance of the benefit, nor return-to-work outcomes, nor safety data. It also does not describe the exercises and physiotherapy in enough detail to reproduce the treatment.

Limitations to keep in mind

A small trial involving 68 participants, described as single-blind without specifying in the abstract who was blinded. Only the PubMed abstract was consulted, not the full text. Some statistical results in the excerpt are incomplete. The clinical relevance of the differences, adverse effects, funding and conflicts of interest could not be verified.

What we can take away

Adding exercises appears to reduce fear-avoidance in the short term in this trial. The additional benefit of shoulder blade exercises remains limited to the work-related dimension, with no evidence presented of better pain relief.

Sources and provenance

Partager cet article

X f in

An error or a source to report? Contact the editorial team.