Protein drinks appear to support rehydration, but the evidence remains limited

Can a protein drink help you rehydrate beyond its nutritional contribution? A systematic review involving 205 adults suggests an advantage over control drinks on several measures of rehydration. But women are underrepresented, and these findings do not demonstrate better recovery or sports performance.

Two glasses of a drink illustrating the comparison of effects on rehydration.
NutritionEditorial illustration, not study data.

Trials mostly conducted after a fluid deficit

The review brings together 16 human studies on drinks containing protein. Of these, 14 involved participants with a fluid deficit and two involved participants who were adequately hydrated at baseline. The meta-analysis results presented in the abstract concern the rehydration studies.

The researchers assessed fluid retention, cumulative urine volume, net fluid balance and changes in plasma volume. These indicators tell us what happens to ingested fluids, not directly how well someone can sustain exercise.

Better fluid retention, not a gain quantifiable in liters

After consumption of drinks containing protein, the pooled results indicate greater fluid retention, lower urine volume and a more favorable net fluid balance than with control drinks. The advantage in plasma volume changes is smaller.

For fluid retention, the standardized mean difference is 0.66, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.39 to 0.93. The authors describe this effect as moderate. This measure allows studies to be pooled, but it means neither 66% more fluid retained nor a specific additional volume.

Drink composition remains a key question

The abstract notes that a drink’s composition can influence gastric emptying and intestinal absorption. These mechanisms lend biological plausibility to the findings, but do not, on their own, demonstrate the effectiveness of protein.

The abstract does not detail the composition of each control drink. It therefore does not allow us to verify how much of the observed differences can be attributed to protein alone, rather than to other characteristics of the drinks compared. Nor does it allow any commercial product to be identified as superior.

The scope remains limited

Women account for only 17.1% of participants. Plant-based protein drinks are also understudied, which limits generalization to these formulations.

The dossier contains only the PubMed abstract, not the full text. Trial duration, heterogeneity, risk of bias and potential adverse effects cannot be examined in detail from this excerpt. Funding and conflicts of interest have not been checked.

Limitations to keep in mind

Small participant pool, low representation of women and a lack of data on plant-based drinks. The abstract alone does not allow a detailed assessment of the comparators, duration of effects, safety or methodological quality of the trials.

What we can take away

Drinks containing protein appear to improve some indicators of rehydration after a fluid deficit. These data are not sufficient to recommend a specific drink or promise a performance benefit.

Sources and provenance

Partager cet article

X f in

An error or a source to report? Contact the editorial team.